10-27-2014 City of Clermont
MINUTES
RED LIGHT VIOLATION HEARING
October 27,2014
The City of Clermont Red Light Violation Heanng for October 27, 2014 took place in the Council
Chambers at City Hall beginning at 9am with Judge Robert Guthrie presiding over the heanng. Clermont
City Clerk Ackroyd served as the heanng clerk. Deputy Clerk Noak assisted with the hearing process.
City Clerk Ackroyd swore in defendants Belen Acevedo, Bo Bnan Burgess, Chnstme Sawyer Charpia,
Ryan Douglas Duffey, Thomas Michael Encrapera, Robert Floyd Henderson, Jacqueline Holden, Linda
Boone Howard, Cecilio Ortiz Atanacio,Noval Bryant Scott, Tonya M Armstrong, Earl Dean Ratliff, Lee
D Stolar, Misty Leigh Sylvia, Gerald P Badalamento, Teodoro Cruz Garcia, Luis Lacostte, Tiffany Lynn
Petruzzi, Pamela Alexandra Valenzuela, Sandra L Washburn, Oswald Lawrence Haye, David Lionel
Leclair, Regina Lynn Toler, Steven Raymond Ali, Christopher Earl Ballard, Gustavo Cordero-Cespedes,
Mildred Fergus, Noah Joseph, Cindy Lynn Mackinnon, Deborah J Morgan, Milton Tu, Robert Zapata,
and Officers Cram and Carter.
Case Number: 4061400089270 Defendant: Belen Acevedo
Officer Carter presented the alleged violation and recommended a minimum court cost of$50 00.
Ms.Acevedo_,presented her defense:
Disposition: Upheld Ticket: $158.00 Court Cost: $50.00 Total: $208.00
Case Number: 4061400094809 Defendant: Marganta Alvarez Mendez
Officer Carter presentedthe alleged violation and recommended a minimum court cost of$50.00.
Ms. Mendez was not present.
Disposition Upheld Ticket: $158.00 Court Cost: $35.00 Total: $193 00
Case Number: 4061400093538 Defendant: Bo Brian Burgess
Officer Carter presented the alleged violation and recommended a minimum court cost of$50.00.
Mr. Burgess presented his defense.
Disposition: Dismissed,no violation Ticket: $0.00 Court Cost: $0.00 Total: $0.00
Case Number: 4061400066450 Defendant: Christine Sawyer Charpia
Officer Carter presented the alleged violation and recommended a minimum court cost of$50.00.
Ms. Charpia presented her defense.
Disposition: Upheld Ticket: $158.00 Court Cost: $50.00 Total. $208.00
Case Number: 4061400049639 Defendant: Ryan Douglas Duffey
Officer Carter presented the alleged violation and recommended a minimum court cost of$50 00.
Mr. Duffey presented his defense.
Disposition: Upheld Ticket: $158.00 Court Cost. $50.00 Total: $208 00
Case Number: 4061400042873 Defendant Thomas Michael Encrapera
Officer Carter presented the alleged violation and recommended a minimum court cost of$50.00.
Mr. Encrapera presented his defense.
Disposition: Upheld Ticket $158.00 Court Cost: $50.00 Total: $208 00
Case Number 4061400093660 Defendant Scott Vincent Fattizzi
Officer Carter presented the alleged violation and recommended a minimum court cost of$50 00.
Mr:Fattizzi was not present.
Disposition: Upheld Ticket $158.00 Court Cost. $35.00 Total: $193.00
1
City of Clermont
MINUTES
RED LIGHT VIOLATION HEARING
October 27, 2014
Case Number. 4061400077762 Defendant: Robert Floyd Henderson
Officer Carter presented the alleged violation and recommended a minimum court cost of$50.00.
Mr.Henderson stated he was not the driver.
Disposition. Waiver provided Ticket $158.00 Court Cost: $0 00 Total: $158.00
Case Number 4061400091326 Defendant. Raymond Harry Holden
Officer Carter presented the alleged violation and recommended a minimum court cost of$50.00.
Ms.Jacqueline Holden presented her defense.
Disposition: Upheld Ticket: $158.00 Court Cost: $50 00 Total: $208.00
Case Number 4061400094619 Defendant: Kathryn D Bolotin
Officer Carter presented the alleged violation and recommended a minimum court cost of$50.00
Ms.Bolotmn checked in and left before her hearing.
Disposition: Upheld Ticket: $158.00 Court Cost: $35.00 Total: $193.00
Case Number: 4061400078901 Defendant: Jacob Adam Gearhart
Officer Carter presented the alleged violation and recommended a minimum court cost of$50.00.
Mr. Gearhart was not present.
Disposition: Upheld Ticket: $158.00 Court Cost: $35.00 Total: $193.00
Case Number 4061400098016 Defendant: Linda Boone Howard
Officer Carter presented the alleged violation and recommended a minimum court cost of$50.00.
Ms.Howard presented her defense.
Disposition: Upheld Ticket: $158.00 Court Cost: $50.00 Total: $208.00
Case Number: 4061400094007 Defendant: Linda Boone Howard
Officer Carter presented the alleged violation and recommended a minimum court cost of$50.00.
Ms Howard presented her defense.
Disposition. Upheld Ticket $158.00 Court Cost. $0.00 Total: $158 00
Case Number: 4061400098313 Defendant: Cecilio Ortiz Atanacio
Officer Carter presented the alleged violation and recommended a minimum court cost of$50.00.
Mr. Ortiz Atanacmo presented his defense.
Disposition: Dismissed,no violation Ticket: $0.00 Court Cost: $0.00 Total. $0.00
Case Number: 4061400094569 Defendant Evelyn T Rodnguez
Officer Carter presented the alleged violation and recommended a minimum court cost of$50.00.
Ms. Rodnguez was not present.
Disposition: Upheld Ticket: $158.00 Court Cost: $35.00 Total: $193.00
Case Number. 4061400092332 Defendant: Noval Bryant Scott
Officer Carter presented the alleged violation and recommended a minimum court cost of$50 00.
Mr. Scott presented his defense.
Disposition: Upheld Ticket. $158.00 Court Cost: $50.00 Total. $208.00
Case Number 4061400095061 Defendant Marganta Alvarez Mendez
Officer Carter presented the alleged violation and recommended a minimum court cost of$50.00.
Ms Mendez was not present.
Disposition Upheld Ticket: $158.00 Court Cost: $35.00 Total: $193.00
2
Cu)'of Clermont
MINUTES
RED LIGHT VIOLATION HEARING
October 27, 2014
Case Number: 4061400062210 Defendant: Tonya M Armstrong
Officer Carter presented the alleged violation and recommended a minimum court cost of$50 00
Ms. Armstrong presented her defense
Disposition: Dismissed,no violation Ticket: $0.00 Court Cost: $0.00 Total: $0 00
Case Number: 4061400099105 Defendant• Damion A Ferran
Officer Carter presented the alleged violation and recommended a minimum court cost of$50.00.
Mr. Ferrari was not present.
Disposition: Upheld Ticket. $158.00 Court Cost $35 00 Total: $193.00
Case Number 4061400087613 Defendant: Earl Dean Ratliff
Officer Carter presented the alleged violation and recommended a minimum court cost of$50.00.
Mr. Ratliff presented his defense.
Disposition: Upheld Ticket: $158 00 Court Cost: $50.00 Total: $208.00
Case Number: 4061400083141 Defendant: Lee D Stolar
Officer Carter presented the alleged violation and recommended a minimum court cost of$50.00.
Mr Stolar presented his defense.
Disposition Dismissed,no violation Ticket: $0.00 Court Cost $0.00 Total: $0.00
Case Number 4061400082341 Defendant: Misty Leigh Sylvia
Officer Carter presented the alleged violation and recommended a minimum court cost of$50.00.
Ms. Sylvia presented her defense.
Disposition: Upheld Ticket: $158.00 Court Cost: $50.00 Total: $208.00
Case Number: 4061400088512 Defendant: Avilder,Inc.
Officer Carter presented the alleged violation and recommended a minimum court cost of$50.00.
Mr.Teodoro Garcia; owner,presented his defense.
Disposition: Dismissed,no violation Ticket: $0.00 Court Cost: $0.00 Total: $0.00
Case Number: 40614000103782 Defendant: Gerald P Badalamento
Officer Carter presented the alleged violation and recommended a minimum court cost of$50.00.
Mr.Badalamento stated he was not the driver
Disposition: Waiver provided Ticket: $158.00 Court Cost: $0.00 Total: $158.00
Case Number: 4061400097141 Defendant. Marlene Hyacmt Blake
Officer Carter presented the alleged violation and recommended a minimum court cost of$50.00
Ms.Blake was not present.
Disposition: Upheld Ticket: $158.00 Court Cost: $35.00 Total $193.00
Case Number: 4061400097190 Defendant: Teodoro Cruz Garcia
Officer Carter presented the alleged violation and recommended a minimum court cost of$50 00.
Mr. Garcia presented his defense
Disposition: Upheld Ticket: $158.00 Court Cost. $50.00 Total $208.00
Case Number: 4061400105324 Defendant: Rosa Lacostte
Officer Carter presented the alleged violation and recommended a minimum court cost of$50.00.
Mr. Luis Lacostte presented his defense.
Disposition: Dismissed, emergency vehicle present Ticket $0.00 Court Cost. $0.00 Total: $0.00
3
City of Clermont
MINUTES
RED LIGHT VIOLATION HEARING
October 27, 2014
Case Number 4061400083554 Defendant: Tiffany Lynn Petruzzi
Officer Carter presented the alleged violation and recommended a minimum court cost of$50.00.
Ms Petruzzi presented her defense
Disposition: Upheld Ticket $158.00 Court Cost: $50.00 Total: $208.00
Case Number: 4061400101224 Defendant Wayne Paul Philbrick
Officer Carter presented the alleged violation and recommended a minimum court cost of$50.00.
Mr Philbnck was not present.
Disposition: Upheld Ticket: $158.00 Court Cost: $35.00 Total: $193.00
Case Number: 4061400083430 Defendant: Pamela Alexandra Valenzuela
Officer Carter presented the alleged violation and recommended a minimum court cost of$50.00
Ms.Valenzuela presented her defense.
Disposition: Upheld Ticket: $158.00 Court Cost: $50.00 Total: $208.00
Case Number: 4061400084529 Defendant: Sandra L Washburn
Officer Carter presented the alleged violation and recommended a minimum court cost of$50.00
Ms. Washburn presented her defense.
Disposition: Upheld Ticket: $158.00 Court Cost: $40.00 Total: $198.00
Case Number: 4061400085310 Defendant: Travis Jordan Reshad Dickens
Officer Carter presented the alleged violation and recommended a minimum court cost of$50.00.
Mr Dickens was not present.
Disposition. Upheld Ticket: $158.00 Court Cost: $35.00 Total $193.00
Case Number: 4061400063853 Defendant: Suzette Nicole Green
Officer Carter presented the alleged violation and recommended a minimum court cost of$50.00.
Ms. Green was not present.
Disposition: Upheld Ticket: $158.00 Court Cost $35.00 Total: $193.00
Case Number: 4061400099071 Defendant: Oswald Lawrence Haye
Officer Carter presented the alleged violation and recommended a minimum court cost of$50.00.
Mr. Haye presented his defense.
Disposition Upheld Ticket: $158.00 Court Cost: $50.00 Total: $208.00
Case Number: 4061400106553 Defendant: David Lionel Leclair
Officer Carter presented the alleged violation and recommended a minimum court cost of$50.00.
Mr. Leclair presented his defense.
Disposition: Dismissed Ticket $0.00 Court Cost: $0.00 Total $0.00
Case Number: 4061400096861 Defendant. Bnan M Monk
Officer Carter presented the alleged violation and recommended a minimum court cost of$50.00.
Attorney Dan Archer presented Mr.Monk's defense
Disposition: Dismissed Ticket: $0.00 Court Cost. $0 00 Total: $0.00
Case Number: 4061400087225 Defendant: Regina Lynn Toler
Officer Carter presented the alleged violation and recommended a minimum court cost of$50 00
Ms.Toler presented her defense.
Disposition: Upheld, 90 days to pay Ticket. $158.00 Court Cost: $40.00 Total: $198 00
4
City of Clermont
MINUTES
RED LIGHT VIOLATION HEARING
October 27, 2014
Case Number: 4061400091276 Defendant: Emil Louis Welch
Officer Carter presented the alleged violation and recommended a minimum court cost of$50.00.
Mr. Welch was not present.
Disposition Upheld Ticket: $158.00 Court Cost. $35.00 Total $193.00
Case Number: 4061400106009 Defendant: Issa Mohammed Abel Jaber
Officer Carter presented the alleged violation and recommended a minimum court cost of$50.00.
Mr.Jaber was not present.
Disposition: Upheld Ticket: $158 00 Court Cost: $35 00 Total: $193.00
Case Number: 4061400099691 Defendant: Steven Raymond Ali
Officer Carter presented the alleged violation and recommended a minimum court cost of$50.00.
Mr. Alm presented his defense.
Disposition: Dismissed,no violation Ticket- $0.00 Court Cost: $0.00 Total: $0.00
Case Number. 4061400088827 Defendant: Christopher Earl Ballard
Officer Carter presented the alleged violation and recommended a minimum court cost of$50.00.
Mr. Ballard presented his defense.
Disposition: Upheld Ticket: $158.00 Court Cost. $50.00 Total: $208.00
Case Number 4061400093934 Defendant. Gustavo Cordero-Cespedes
Officer Carter presented the alleged violation and recommended a minimum court cost of$50.00.
Mr. Cordero-Cespedes presented his defense.
Disposition: Upheld Ticket: $158.00 Court Cost: $50.00 Total: $208.00
Case Number: 4061400096135 Defendant: Mildred Fergus
Officer Carter presented the alleged violation and recommended a minimum court cost of$50.00.
Ms Fergus presented her defense.
Disposition: Dismissed,no violation Ticket: $0.00 Court Cost: $0.00 Total: $0.00
Case Number: 4061400106157 Defendant: Noah Joseph
Officer Carter presented the alleged violation and recommended a minimum court cost of$50.00.
Ms.Joseph presented her defense.
Disposition. Dismissed,no violation Ticket $0.00 Court Cost: $0.00 Total: $0.00
Case Number: 4061400086425 Defendant: Cindy Lynn Mackinnon
Officer Carter presented the alleged violation and recommended a minimum court cost of$50.00
Ms.Mackinnon presented her defense.
Disposition: Upheld Ticket: $158.00 Court Cost: $50.00 Total: $208.00
Case Number: 4061400108302 Defendant: Deborah J Morgan
Officer Scheller presented the alleged violation and recommended a minimum court cost of$50.00.
Ms.Morgan presented her defense.
Disposition. Upheld Ticket: $158.00 Court Cost: $50.00 Total: $208.00
Case Number: 4061400075915 Defendant. Milton Tu
Officer Carter presented the alleged violation and recommended a minimum court cost of$50.00
Mr.Tu presented his defense.
Disposition: Dismissed,no violation Ticket: $0.00 Court Cost. $0.00 Total. $0.00
5
City of Clermont
MINUTES
RED LIGHT VIOLATION HEARING
October 27, 2014
Case Number: 4061400094353 Defendant. Robert Zapata
Officer Carter presented the alleged violation and recommended a nummum court cost of$50.00.
Mr. Zapata presented his defense
Disposition: Dismissed,no violation Ticket: $0.00 Court Cost: $0.00 Total: $0.00
With no further scheduled heanngs,the hearing adjourned at 3:45pm
6